Published on September 29, 2026
SEO Daily Update: September 27, 2026
By Ben Murphy
Your AI Citations Could Be Worthless
AI citations have become the new agency trophy, “We got your website cited by ChatGPT.”
This sounds great but there is an awkward problem.
Research into AI citations has highlighted what Semrush calls “ghost citations”. An AI answer can use and cite a website without mentioning the brand in the generated response.
In Semrush’s analysis, 61.7% of the citations studied were ghost citations, meaning the cited brand was not actually mentioned in the answer.
That creates a pretty important distinction.
A citation does not automatically equal brand visibility. And brand visibility does not automatically equal traffic, leads or revenue.
You can technically “win” the AI citation and still be completely invisible to the person reading the answer.
The GEO Reporting Problem
This is where GEO reporting can start getting dangerously close to the old-school rankings reports we spent years trying to move clients away from.
Big numbers look impressive.
50 AI citations.
100 citations.
500 citations.
But what did they actually do?
If ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or another answer engine uses your website to construct an answer but never tells the user who supplied that information, the commercial value becomes considerably harder to prove.
Your content helped the AI. Your brand potentially got nothing.
That does not make citations useless. Far from it. Being repeatedly selected as a source can tell us something important about how answer engines perceive the authority and usefulness of a website.
The mistake is treating the citation itself as the result.
Action
f you are investing in GEO strategies, stop treating citation counts as the headline KPI. A citation sounds impressive, but it means very little on its own.
Instead, separate the journey into four signals:
- Citation: Did the AI system use your website as a source?
- Mention: Did it actually name your business?
- Click: Did anyone visit your website?
- Commercial outcome: Did that visibility generate an enquiry, lead or sale?
That gives you a much more honest picture of whether your AI visibility is actually doing anything commercially useful.
Until those four signals are separated, a GEO report can make virtually meaningless visibility look impressive.
What Businesses Should Actually Be Measuring
This does not mean abandoning AI citation tracking. It means putting it in context.
If your citations are increasing alongside branded mentions, referral traffic and enquiries, brilliant. You have evidence that your GEO activity is creating genuine visibility.
If citations are climbing while everything else remains flat, you need to ask a harder question. Are we becoming more visible, or are we simply becoming a better free data source for somebody else’s AI?
That is a lot more useful of a conversation than celebrating another citation dashboard.
PunkFox Take
AI citations are starting to become the new rankings report.
A lovely number to put in a presentation. Considerably less useful if nobody sees your brand, clicks your website or buys anything.
The metric itself is not useless.
Treating the metric as the result is.
GEO needs commercial KPIs before it becomes another vanity-metric industry.